Problem:
Find the number of rectangles inside a fixed regular dodecagon (12-gon) where each side of the rectangle lies on a side or on a diagonal of the dodecagon. The diagram below shows three of those rectangles
Solution:
In what follows, the word "diagonal" means "diagonal or side of the dodecagon", and "parallel" is used in the inclusive sense where a line (or segment) is thought of as being parallel to itself.
Let P=A1βA2ββ¦A12β be the regular dodecagon. Any rectangle whose sides lie along the diagonals of this 12-gon must have one pair of sides parallel to one of the segments A1βA2ββ,A1βA3ββ,A1βA4ββ,A1βA5ββ,A1βA6ββ, or A1βA7ββ.
For each of the diagonals A1βA2ββ,A1βA4ββ, and A1βA6ββ, there are 5 other diagonals of the dodecagon parallel to it. For the other three diagonals, A1βA3ββ,A1βA5ββ, and A1βA7ββ, there are 4 other diagonals parallel to it, as shown in the examples below.
Consider the case of rectangles with sides parallel to A1βA2ββ. The two sides of the rectangle parallel to A1βA2ββ lie along 2 of 6 possible diagonals, so there are (26β)=15 possible pairs of diagonals.
- If the shorter of these two diagonals has length A1βA2β (9 of the 15 pairs), there are only 2 possible diagonals perpendicular to A1βA2β for the other two sides of the rectangle, and thus there is only 1 choice for those sides.
- If the shorter of these two diagonals has length A3βA12β (5 of the 15 pairs), there are 4 possible diagonals perpendicular to A1βA2β for the other two sides of the rectangle, and thus there are (24β)=6 choices for those sides.
- If the shorter of these two diagonals has length A4βA11β (1 of the 15 pairs), there are 6 possible diagonals perpendicular to A1βA2β for the other two sides of the rectangle, and thus there are (26β)=15 choices for those sides.
Therefore there are 9β
1+5β
6+1β
15=54 rectangles with two sides parallel to A1βA2ββ. Similarly, there are 54 rectangles with sides parallel to A1βA4ββ and 54 with sides parallel to A1βA6ββ for a total of 3β
54=162 rectangles in this case.
Consider the case of rectangles with sides parallel to A1βA3ββ. The two sides of the rectangle parallel to A1βA3ββ lie along 2 of 5 possible diagonals, so there are (25β)=10 possible pairs of diagonals.
- If the shorter of these two diagonals has length A1βA3β (7 of the 10 pairs), there are 3 possible diagonals perpendicular to A1βA3β for the other two sides of the rectangle, and thus there are (23β)=3 choices for those sides.
- If the shorter of these two diagonals has length A4βA12β (3 of the 10 pairs), there are 5 possible diagonals perpendicular to A1βA3β for the other two sides of the rectangle, and thus there are (25β)=10 choices for those sides.
Therefore there are 7β
3+3β
10=51 rectangles with two sides parallel to A1βA3ββ. Similarly, there are 51 rectangles with sides parallel to A1βA5ββ and 51 with sides parallel to A1βA7ββ for a total of 3β
51=153 rectangles in this case.
The total number of rectangles is 162+153=315β.
OR
Let A1βA2ββ¦A12β be the regular dodecagon, and consider a rectangle whose edges lie on A1βAcββ,AdβAgββ,AaβAfββ, and AbβAeββ for some
1β€a<bβ€c<dβ€e<fβ€gβ€12,
as shown in the next diagram.
Because opposite sides are parallel, it must be that h1β=dβc=13βg and h2β=bβa=fβe for some h1β,h2ββ₯1. Let m=h1β+h2ββ₯2. Because
12β₯(bβa)+(dβc)+(fβe)+(13βg)=2m,
it must be that 2β€mβ€6.
Let k1β=aβ1,k2β=cβb,k3β=eβd, and k4β=gβf, so that kiββ₯0 for all i. In order for A1βAcββ to be perpendicular to AaβAfββ, it must be that
6=(aβ1)+(dβc)+(eβd)+(fβe)=k1β+k3β+m,
so that k1β+k3β=6βm, and similarly k2β+k4β=6βm.
To select a rectangle, first choose m satisfying 2β€mβ€6, and note that
- there are mβ1 choices for h1ββ₯1 and h2ββ₯1 such that h1β+h2β=m;
- there are 7βm choices for k1ββ₯0 and k3ββ₯0 such that k1β+k3β=6βm;
- and likewise there are 7βm choices for k2β and k4β.
There are therefore
1β
52+2β
42+3β
32+4β
22+5β
12=105
of these rectangles.
This count was done starting with the location of A1β, but the count could have been done by starting with any of the 12 vertices. Because each rectangle has 4 sides, multiplying the above count of 105 by 12 would overcount by a factor of 4. It follows that the total number of rectangles is 4105β
12β=315β.
The problems on this page are the property of the MAA's American Mathematics Competitions